Contact Us

Why Most Linkbuilding Agencies Fail the CMO Test—and How to Choose a Partner You Can Trust

For CMOs, the promise of “high-quality links” from agency partners often ends in disappointment, wasted budget, and heightened risk. According to a recent Forrester report, over 60% of CMOs surveyed said they were dissatisfied with the ROI delivered by their SEO or link building agencies, citing lack of transparency and failure to deliver sustainable results (Forrester, 2024). This dissatisfaction persists in a market where link building agencies are plentiful, yet only 2.2% of published web pages actually earn more than one backlink (Sure Oak, 2024).

As Prism PR has seen with leading brands, the right approach to link building can transform both SEO and reputation. But finding a trustworthy, CMO-ready partner has never been more challenging—or more essential.

PR-first link building isn’t just a marketing buzzword—it’s the modern standard that sets apart sustainable SEO from short-lived gains. Unlike traditional methods that rely on guest posting, paid placements, or mass outreach, PR-first link building focuses on earning editorial links through newsworthy content and genuine media relationships.

Traditional link building often prioritizes volume over quality, neglecting the authority and long-term value that only genuine editorial links can provide.

Here’s what real, modern PR-first link building includes today:

As Google’s John Mueller recently stated, “Links that are earned organically from authoritative sites have a much more lasting impact than those placed through schemes or manipulative tactics” (Search Engine Journal, 2024).

This shift means brands seeking lasting gains must align with agencies who use white-hat, PR-first link building approaches—not outdated shortcuts.

Deep dive into why real PR—not guest post link schemes—is the only safe bet.

It’s a common frustration: agencies over-promise and under-deliver, leaving CMOs to clean up the mess. According to a 2024 SEMrush survey, 45% of marketers have switched agencies within the past year due to a lack of results or trust issues (SEMrush, 2024).

The most common agency pitfalls include:

Such black-hat approaches, like private blog networks or paid links, now routinely trigger search engine penalties.

As one CMO put it in a recent Demand Gen Report, “Trust is everything. We need partners who show their work, not just talk about it.”

For CMOs, these failures translate directly into wasted budget and increased brand risk.

Learn more about the dead giveaways of a low-value link building agency.

The Real Risks—Google’s 2024 Policy Shifts and What They Mean for Brands

Too many brands focus on the volume of acquired links, without recognizing that Google’s standards are getting stricter every year.

Key takeaway: A single misstep can erase years of SEO investment.

In 2024, Google’s spam updates and revised site reputation policies led to a 40% reduction in low-quality, unoriginal content in search results, and numerous sites lost rankings or were penalized for manipulative practices (Search Engine Journal, 2024). Elizabeth Tucker, Google’s Director of Product for Search, noted, “We’re making algorithmic enhancements to ensure we surface the most helpful information on the web and reduce unoriginal content in search results.”

These updates specifically target site reputation abuse, scaled content abuse, and expired domain abuse—leaving little room for error for brands and agencies alike.

Brands that cut corners or work with non-compliant agencies now face greater risks than ever before.

For a deeper look, see why editorial PR is the last safe haven for SEO in Google’s anti-spam era.

Choosing a partner in today’s market requires more than a slick pitch deck. The most trustworthy SEO partners share a few critical differentiators:

Prism PR’s team, comprised of veteran journalists and PR experts, has delivered over 5,100 stories and 2,550+ high-value editorial backlinks for brands like NBA, Nike, and UNICEF.

As Forrester’s 2024 CMO survey emphasized, “Transparency in process and proof of work are the top factors separating trusted partners from the rest.”

To see our approach to editorial link building, visit our SEO link building page.

High-authority, editorial-only link building produces tangible results that generic outreach never can. For example, in the SaaS sector, companies that adopted PR-first strategies saw a 38% average increase in organic traffic within six months, with placements in outlets like Forbes, Mashable, and CNET (DemandSage, 2024).

Prism PR’s editorial campaigns consistently deliver DA 70–94 links and real coverage in national media.

This DA range is a key differentiator, as most agencies struggle to consistently secure links above DA 50.

To see more earned media coverage and proof, visit our strategic PR campaigns.

Selecting the right agency is a make-or-break decision for CMOs. Use this checklist:

  1. Ask about acquisition methods: Do they use only white-hat, editorial-first strategies?
  2. Demand transparency: Will they show you every link and explain each placement?
  3. Check for pay-for-performance: Do you only pay for delivered results?
  4. Assess content quality: Are their assets newsworthy and data-driven?
  5. Request references: Can they provide real examples of success in your industry?

Remember, 93.8% of successful link builders now prioritize link quality over quantity, underscoring the importance of thorough agency vetting.

According to a 2024 Authority Hacker survey, CMOs who use a structured vetting process are 60% more likely to report satisfaction with agency outcomes (Authority Hacker, 2024).

For more, see the questions every CMO should ask before hiring a linkbuilding agency.

SEO is changing rapidly. In March 2024, Google’s documentation removed the term “important” from the description of links as a ranking factor, signaling a shift toward broader quality signals (Search Engine Journal, 2024). John Mueller noted, “Links are just one of many signals we use, and their relative weight continues to decrease as we improve our systems” (Google Search Central, 2024).

CMOs should adapt by prioritizing content quality, brand authority, and genuine publisher relationships.

The rise of AI-generated content also means brands must ensure every asset provides original, user-focused value to avoid future algorithm penalties.

Staying ahead now means investing in strategies that are resilient to algorithm changes and focused on real-world reputation.

Learn more in the new playbook for PR in the SEO era.

Conclusion & Next Steps—Building Authority with Confidence

In today’s high-stakes SEO environment, only partners who deliver link building best practices and proof of real, editorial results can be trusted. Prism PR’s pay-for-performance, PR-first approach safeguards your brand’s authority and delivers DA 50–90+ links that move the needle.

Explore how pay-for-performance and true editorial PR-first link building can safeguard your brand from Google’s next big update.

Don’t settle for promises—demand results, transparency, and proof.

Ready to see the difference? Review our proven client successes and schedule a strategy session with Prism PR today.

References

Quick Links
Services
Contact Us
Subscribe for our Newsletter
Copyright 2025 Prism PR. All Rights Reserved.
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions